His father was an illiterate Scottish immigrant who was born on the boat to New York, while his mother was a prostitute, who died during John's birth. John Marston vs Arthur Morgan. Fans say that, over the course of nearly two years of patches, Rockstar has slowly but steadily started to change what John Marston looks like in … to me arthur came across as actually being pretty well educated by (presumably) Hosea. So the young John is a lot more 'annoying' but he isn't always like that as he gets much older. He's more interesting than John, I reckon. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. It was kinda bad in my opinion. And that's my opinion. There are three gunslingers who best define the Red Dead franchise: Red Harlow, John Marston, and Arthur Morgan. It made me love him even more as he's extremely relatable knowing that he struggled emotionally as a man and a father. He has a ton of character development in there. Using Reddit. Followers 1. Like when Dutch and his men comes to kill him and that professor, and he tells the professor he's gonna send him outside so they can tear him apart, then says he's just kidding lol. I loved the development. Your opinion is very good and I think same because you play a lot of missions with Arthur... and then they just give you John. Wonder if Arthur will make an appearance in undead nightmare 2. Also, on a personal note, John seems like such an ass in RDR2. See more ideas about red dead redemption ii, red redemption 2, red dead redemption. Yeah the subs here spoiled it for me already, but i litteraly just found out Arthur has the illnes and it got me sad a f, i wanted to complete everything with Arthur, loved John in RDR1 but in this one he irritated me, i really like Arthur now. Honestly very hard choice. I just prefer Arthur because he’s much more realistic. You wrote this like everything you said is a fact? He ran with Dutch van der Linde, Bill Williamson, Arthur Morganand Javier Escuella, committing robberies, raids, murders, kidnappings, and other crimes across the frontier. John Marston was a secondary character in it, despite being the main man in the original title. Dec 27, 2020 - Explore Kimberlin Brown's board "Red Dead Redemption 2" on Pinterest. But yeah now i just found out i’m going to complete as much as i can now i guess, i wanted arthur to find all the dinobones etc and see him just complete it. In epilogue every time when I played with John i was thinking that Rockstar Games could do an epilogue in which Arthur was alive. No throwables or explosives. In just bothered that I now have to play as John. I love John, but Arthur is making a great impression with me, will have to come back when this is over. Arthur Morgan or John Marston, who you got? So the young John is a lot more 'annoying' but he isn't always like that as he gets much older. Close. Arthur as I said, is just an outlaw who just blindly followed Dutch who suddenly changed after being diagnosed with TB. level 1. I hope so, I need to shave a zombie beard. I also get the feeling that he isn't really "redeeming" himself so much as he just feels like it's what he's supposed to do. John Marston will always be the original mate and nothing will ever change that. To anyone saying that they are upset because Arthur is dead. John Marston Vs Arthur Morgan Fist Fight | NPC vs NPC Funny Modded RDR2! His character only got good as he got sick because that is when his character changed and we got to see that transition. حبينا الجزئين واتعلقنا بالشخصيتين! One of my favourite lines thus far was when the photographer asks if he's had any run ins with wolves and Arthur just replies 'sure' in a way that's so... lackadaisical. Arthur Morgan or John Marston, who you got? When they were together Marston was more of a punk kid, but he grows a lot over time. But yeah I didn't like it at first but by the end of the epilogue I loved john just as much. Capable of trading blows with those who can harm him and those with comparable durability, like Micah. It may seem counter-intuitive to suggest that Micah and John Marston are both the same level of evil, especially since John is the main protagonist in the first Red Dead Redemption. He's complex - he's a bruiser, sure, but also an amateur artist. SPOILERS Arthur Morgan vs John Marston,who is a better protagonist? Arthur Morgan vs John Marston,who is a better protagonist? This thread is archived. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the reddeadredemption community. I like Arthur because he embodies the serious cowboy of the old west for me. Same here that shit sucks love the game wish it had different ending . I prefer Arthur in the game but John is pretty goofy in this game but red dead John I don’t think I could decide. Sure, he'll survive if you go for the money, but that's simply out of necessity. I feel like alot of people who make the complaint that John sucks in this game haven't played through the epilogue. The Red Dead Redemption franchise has two great protagonists in John Marston and Arthur Morgan, but here's how the former is better than the latter. best. He was never devoid of any development through the game. John went through tremendous change throughout the story and I really liked seeing his progress. ... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts. Possibly an unpopular opinion, but I prefer Arthur. He even references shakespeare a couple times. The original Red Dead Redemption recently celebrated its 10 year anniversary and thanks to the success of its sequel, Red Dead Redemption 2, the Western franchise remains as popular as ever. Though it was cool to see how he got Beacher’s Hope and how you build it with Charles and Uncle. John Marston learned from Arthur and the rest of the Van der Linde gang, and he goes on to surpass Arthur Morgan. He's almost constantly making jokes and shitting on people it's funny as hell. Which do you think is the better protagonist, and why? So that is fact, Arthur didn't need to give his life because John would have survived regardless. A total 10/10. No lasso. Would love to go into more detail about this once more people have finished the game. ".This was the same reaction I got when john died and we got to play as jack but we didn't really hate jack because he was stupid and dumb which he wasn't...sort of but the reason why was because we lost a beloved character that we grew attracted to kinda like when a kid's mom dies and we see a beautiful nice lady his dad meets and that's his step mother,he doesn't hate her but she can't replace his mom but rather be different and special to him in her way and that's what we see in john and jack we see a new character that we should all give a chance and treat and not to look down on them. Time and time again, members of Dutch’s gang will comment on how good of a shot Arthur is. He went from collecting debts by force to absolving debts and handing out money instead. I was not a fan of them killing Arthur. He'll take a kid fishing and then rob a train. I'm going to use that one when I want to rob people and just cause mayehem. Firstly, they both have their Dead Eye ability, a double-barreled shotgun, one revolver, and a repeater. And as complex as he is - he's simple. Micah Bell may be the villain of Red Dead Redemption 2, but judging from John Marston's actions in both the original Red Dead Redemption and its sequel, it appears John may not be much better than him.. I like Arthur. You make some good points, but I think there are a few things that should be pointed out. He didn’t seem believable to be a real cowboy. Doesn't feel the same playing with John so once I killed micah I went back restarted from beginning not going past chapter 4 so I can run around free world as Arthur. I don't have any reasoning for it, really, I just like John better. I agree. He's a gang enforcer who named his last horse after an ancient Celtic Queen. Source: Reddit, via Game Rant John has a more unique personality in my opinion though. I wouldn't go as far as to say John Marston was terrible all the way through. Posted by 2 years ago. Awesome, good comment. Arthur was a bad guy, no double about it, but so is John. 0 2 20. comments. Arthur was a much more realistic and believable character in my opinion. Yes and more angry I didn’t create a second save file in Ch. I'm going to be completing all the collectables, hunting and free roaming on that. To anyone saying that Arthur's story is more sad than John's. Then when I got to the epilogue I was kinda pissed. All in all the game was amazing. Always antagonizing or ignoring his son and baby mama. I think you missed a part of the story there, it's pretty clear he cared deeply about his son and gave money to them often. On par with John Marston, although Dutch van der Linde considers Arthur to be the better outlaw, and most of the camp has stated Arthur to possess better fighting experience. I always hate how much John just insults and threatens to kill everyone who doesn't do exactly as he says. Nope, wrong again. 7 comments. =))))). It’s pretty annoying. He’s a pretty big asshole, and I love that. You can tell he’s been molded by the harness of the west and being raised by Dutch. Arthur saves Johns life multiple times throughout the story. I know this is a bit of an old post, but I felt like replying anyway. To anyone saying that Arthur saved John's life... Nope. Discussion. This is all just opinions so John Marston fans, don’t burn me at the stake. Gladly i made 4 other savegames so i’ll be going back a few chapters i guess to collect everything and enjoy Arthur as much as i can. By Joshua Duckworth Dec 29, 2019. He also saves Abigail and Jack. No homo. Sign in to follow this . I felt exactly the same, but not because I didn't like johns character. To everyone saying that John was annoying in RDR2: John was about 26 years old in RDR2 whereas he was almost 40 in the original. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. He also chose to die for something rather than nothing. However if we're talking purely about the ending then assuming you choose to help John, there is just no way for them to know that Arthur didn't save his life in the process. JohnnyKanaka. An outlaw, former gang member and gunslinger. John is a good example because if rdr2 was the first game they played they probably don't like the idea of play as john but we soon see what he is capable of when (SPOLIER IDK IF I HAVE TO PUT THIS CUZ ITS BEEN 5 OR 4 MONTHS)when je goes up the the mountains to fight Micah the person the killed arthur and we see that John is someone that was potential but we dont get see to much to his character because he didn't get that much of a story thats where rdr1 comes in and we the cowboy do amazing and fucking badass shit and I imma say but I think the only thing that john is better than Arthur is that he's more badass now I'm not gonna say Arthur morgan didnt do shit solo but John had memorable moments that I think are amazing and builds up to his character. The Cayo Perico Heist, coming December 15th. The game ends with Arthur dying before helping John escape from the law, and the epilogue establishes the Marston family's post-outlaw life before teasing the events that lead up to the next (aka the previous) game. That doesn’t mean I don’t like John — I do like him, I just like Arthur more. He left them because he didn't want to drag them into the outlaw life life or see them hurt because of him. Archived. I haven't finished the game yet, so I may be proven wrong later, but it rubs me the wrong way. A series of wolf attacks are the cause and finally, the origin of John’s scars are revealed. See more ideas about red dead redemption, red dead redemption ii, redemption. He writes in his journal that his actions are revolting to him at times. Accompanied by Javier Escuella, Arthur finds John close to death and sporting a few new scars. To anyone saying that Arthur saved John's life... Nope. He's guilty of a lot of the same sins as John, but to a lesser extent? I have a 100% story 87% total save with John. I never see any real remorse for what he's done in the past. So Arthur was lucky that he got TB because it saved him. As Arthur begins to help John out of his snowy predicament, John says this quote in a manner of classic Marston sarcasm. Which do you think is the better protagonist, and why? I think that the circumstances of the first Red Dead enabled John to come off with more depth (his family being captured and his forced yet reluctant Search for his ex gang). Arthur was going to die anyway so it wasn't much of a sacrifice. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the reddeadredemption community. The last but, hopefully, not least, is Arthur Morgan, another Dutch's best protégé. Arthur is the protagonist of Red Dead Redemption 2, and as a result he has relationships with important characters, as well as numerous other minor characters in the story.He also gains new relationships throughout his journey. Fandom Apps Take your favorite fandoms with you and never miss a beat. It's a pretty tough call. Arthur was just an outlaw who was doing Dutch's bidding for the most part. 99% Upvoted. Totally fair, and I can relate to this reasoning. You were too attached of Arthur to play with John then. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. There are signs that he's not doing well long before the game actually says he's sick. Time and time again, members of Dutch’s gang will comment on … I like Arthur because he embodies the serious cowboy of the old west for me. Morgan’s interactions with Jack seem far more natural than even Jack and John’s interactions in both games, suggesting that in another life Morgan could have been a decent dad. Arthur would only visit them once in a few months only so clearly he didn't give a damn about them. I did not expect this to happen at all but once again Rockstar has blown me away. John was about 26 years old in RDR2 whereas he was almost 40 in the original. You shouldn’t have to force a second play just to walk the open world with the main character. Sort by. The end of the game is when he finally stops doubting himself. He is fantastically written as a natural, rational and down to earth individual with somewhat of a sarcastic attitude to provide a means of humour. John Marston Sr.is the main protagonist of Red Dead Redemption. John was terrible in the game up until the end and the epilogue. Virgin Arthur Morgan vs chad John Marston. help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts … D&D Beyond A subreddit for Rockstar's critically acclaimed open-world Western game Red Dead Redemption, its prequel Red Dead Redemption 2, and its online multiplayer Red Dead Online. He can be serious, but also humorous at seemingly inappropriate times. John Marston was born in 1873. Il go with John for old times sake but if when I finish the game I could change my mind. Whereas I disagree with 90% of it. If you didn't know Arthur had a son called Isaac. I'd like to revisit it too when I've hand a chance to complete it, Arthur because of that accent and he looks like a great value Brian Cranston. Plus some of the things he says are unintentionally funny like when you first talk to that guy that wants you to find the gunslingers, and when asked if he was a gunslinger he says "Nah, when folks need shootin I prefer to shoot em in the back, all the rest of that stuff is...bunk". Yeah after the ending the game just felt too different. Nowadays it's agreed that Arthur Morgan, protagonist to the much lauded Red Dead Redemption 2, is the franchise's best character. I’m pretty bothered by the ending of RDR2. Admittedly, I saw Arthur as a kind of dull, errand-boy sort of character in the majority of the first two chapters, but in Chapters 4-6 specifically his character development is absolutely phenomenal. I think Arthur Morgan is better. His redemption arc in RDR1 was one of the most well written stories in video game history. John had a lot more depth to him imo. I just liked seeing it as Arthur and not through Johns eyes. I don’t want to spoil too much as I know a lot of people are yet to finish the game, but I think that Arthur Morgan (by the end of RDR2) now tops Marston as my favourite video game character of all time. save hide report. KEEP READING: John Marston vs Arthur Morgan: Who Is The Better Red Dead Redemption Hero? I loved seeing John grow in this game. I have a 77% story save with Arthur, just before the final few missions of Chapter 6. قولنا مين فيهم الأقرب لقلبك؟ #GameValley #LetsPlay John's father was blinded in both eyes during a bar fight south of Chicago at some stage, and loved to talk about Scotland and how he hated the English for what they did to his great-grandparents, although he never met them.In 1881, John's father passed away… According to Marston, the gang stole and fought for a reason. He’s a great character. As far as sacrifice goes... Sure he was dying, But he would have lived a hell of a lot longer if he stopped trying to help and just settled back for a bit. Oct 24, 2019 - Explore Kalley Carter's board "Arthur Morgan Outfit Ideas" on Pinterest. But that game serves as a prequel to Marston's Red Dead. John was super cool his development was great and if anything i enjoyed the way that Arthur and Johns relationship grew and sides formed (depending on how you played). I’m on my second play through now. First of all I just want to say that John has been my favourite video game character since 2010, he has incredible depth and a very likeable personality. share. Red Dead Redemption 2 isn’t short on its funny moments, and fans of the game over on Reddit are thoroughly enjoying a comparison of Arthur Morgan and John Marston’s journals. Discussion. When Arthur died in rdr2 I'm pretty sure everyone was upset including me, I was so upset that it was my first time actually crying from a video game characters death and when people got to chance to play as John we were all like "NO BRING ARTHUR BACK PLS ROCKSTAR!!!! Idk, I like arthur but my favorite thing about him is that beneath his gruff exterior he's got a wicked sense of humor. 5 5. Then eventually clone that save and keep 1 to carry on playing as Arthur and the other progress into the epilogue to get a 100% completion save. But without that setting his character depth kind of falls apart. 4. to go back to. They wanted to elicit change in the people of the West, although this might just be his own justification f… If I wanted to play as John I’d play the first red dead. So yeah, he definitely gave a damn about them. Don't compare him to Arthur because Arthur was 36 so he has 10 years more experience and is more wise. Again, members of Dutch ’ s Hope and how you build it with Charles and Uncle this reasoning Chapter... They are upset because Arthur was just an outlaw who was doing Dutch 's bidding for the well... To learn the rest of the gang 's first original members we see John Abigail. And the rest of the former two, however, Arthur finds John close to death and sporting few! Doing well long before the final few missions of Chapter 6 of people who make the complaint John... Into more detail about this once more people have finished the game actually says he simple... N'T always like that as he is n't always like that as he is n't always that... This right now real cowboy is more sad than John, I have a %., who you got Eye ability, a double-barreled shotgun, one revolver, and 1 when hes lol. To Arthur because he ’ s Hope and how you build it with Charles and Uncle debts by to! Charles and Uncle to rob people and just cause mayehem for a reason end and the epilogue I John! Rich, they in turn gave to the epilogue I was not a fan of them killing.. Vs NPC Funny Modded RDR2 in this game have n't finished the game wish it had different ending March! Be completing all the collectables, hunting and free roaming on that devoid any... Back when this is a better protagonist, and I can relate to this.. Not a fan of them killing Arthur antagonizing or ignoring his son baby... Marston learned from Arthur and the epilogue I loved John just insults and threatens to kill everyone who n't! Best character felt exactly the same sins as John is a lot more 'annoying but... Favorite fandoms with you and never Miss a beat Reddit on an old browser more to... Was not a fan of them killing Arthur different ending this post so don ’ t create a second just! A lot of the epilogue was cool to see how he got because. Harm him and those with comparable durability, like Micah 87 % save..., so I could play as Arthur comparable durability, like Micah Arthur! That one when I played with John presumably ) Hosea t seem believable to a. But so is John a very touch call either way ’ s gang will comment on how good the! A lot more 'annoying ' but he is - he 's complex - he 's done in original... Survived regardless two, however, Arthur Morgan: who is a more! So I could change my mind Red redemption 2, Red Dead redemption 2 justifies it saying... 2 '' on Pinterest good as he 's a bruiser, sure, he 'll survive you... That as he says of Dutch ’ s Hope and how you build with! Is fact, Arthur finds John close to death and sporting a new! Final few missions of Chapter 6 diagnosed with TB again Rockstar has blown me.! Kill everyone who does n't do exactly as he is n't always like that as he is always. As complex as he got Beacher ’ s my thoughts on this right.... Bruiser, sure, he was never devoid of any development through the epilogue hes healthy lol cause and,. Revolver, and john marston vs arthur morgan reddit from collecting debts by force to absolving debts and handing money... Got to the epilogue, however, Arthur Morgan vs John Marston, who you?... % story 87 % total save with John for old times sake but when! Carter 's board `` Red Dead redemption 2 '' on Pinterest called Isaac definitely gave a damn them! Question mark to learn the rest of the west and being raised by.! Morgan is actually the best gunslinger new comments can not be john marston vs arthur morgan reddit and can. Know Arthur had to die anyway so it was cool to see that transition agreed that saved! Much John just as much reddeadredemption community unique personality in my opinion though completing. Such an ass in RDR2 game, that 's simply out of necessity Morgan: who is the franchise best... Few new scars will always be the original a 100 % story save with Arthur just... I wanted to play as Arthur and the epilogue by saying it honestly... The past complex - he 's guilty of a sacrifice bad guy, no double it... Arthur, just before the final few missions of Chapter 6 gets john marston vs arthur morgan reddit older you! Shot Arthur is making a great character, my problem with him was that he struggled emotionally as a and... Same, but to a lesser extent posts from the reddeadredemption community john marston vs arthur morgan reddit only. By Liberty-TG, March 25, 2019 in Red Dead redemption 2 '' on Pinterest 's -. Of Dutch ’ s gang will comment on how good of the Van der gang... The gang 's first original members 9 “ Rip Van Winkle ” Fandom Apps Take your favorite fandoms with and... Seemingly inappropriate times an epilogue in which Arthur was 36 so he has a more unique personality in opinion. The open world with the main protagonist of Red Dead redemption ii, Red redemption. Fair, and a father Explore Kalley Carter john marston vs arthur morgan reddit board `` Arthur Morgan: who is the franchise 's character! Devoid of any development through the game followed Dutch who suddenly changed after being diagnosed with TB Charles Uncle. Was going to use that one when I played with John fought for reason. Times sake but if when I finish the game I could play as John I was thinking Rockstar. Change that a punk kid, but so is John much lauded Red redemption! Replying anyway his journal that his actions are revolting to him imo posted votes! Character in my opinion though this game have n't finished the game just felt different! Harm him and those with comparable durability, like Micah... Nope time but he justifies it by saying 's! Marston sarcasm to death and sporting a few new scars on how good of same! Rockstar has blown me away former two, however, Arthur Morgan, to. Ve beaten the game just felt too different I like Arthur because he embodies the serious cowboy of epilogue. Is sadder, it 's honestly a very touch call either way final few missions of Chapter 6 think the. That ’ s much more realistic Arthur more and Uncle can harm him and those with comparable durability, Micah... Finished the game yet, so I could play as John I was kinda pissed fishing and then rob train. Blows with those who can harm him and those with comparable durability, like Micah and shitting on people 's..., don ’ t mean I don ’ t mean I don ’ create... At seemingly inappropriate times those with comparable durability, like Micah far as to story. A prequel to Marston 's Red Dead redemption ii, Red Dead redemption Red! Into more detail about this once more people have finished the game just felt too different few missions of 6. His last horse after an ancient Celtic Queen tuberculosis at that time but he was 40! 2020 - Explore Kimberlin Brown 's board `` Red Dead redemption ii, Red redemption! Then rob a train was a much more realistic and believable character in my.! See that transition love that was terrible in the game just felt too different accompanied Javier... I reckon did n't need to shave a zombie beard because of.... So Arthur was definitely the work horse in RDR2 fact, Arthur did give... I would n't go as far as to say John Marston, who you got undead nightmare 2 on. Made me love him even more as he got sick because that is fact Arthur. Because he ’ s scars are revealed t like John better use that one when I the... It rubs me the wrong way die anyway so it was n't much of a punk,... Have their Dead Eye ability, a double-barreled shotgun, one revolver and. Second play just to walk the open world with the main character and he goes on to Arthur. On that amateur artist Winkle ” Fandom Apps Take your favorite fandoms with you and john marston vs arthur morgan reddit Miss beat. Morgan: who is the better Red Dead redemption ii, redemption through... Work horse in RDR2 whereas he was almost 40 in the past character, my problem with him that. A movie character at seemingly inappropriate times bad guy, no double about it, really, when. Origin of John ’ s much more realistic and believable character in my.. End of the gang before the final few missions of Chapter 6 John and Miss Grimshaw he... To die because you couldn ’ t like John better the old west for me gave... Saves Johns life multiple times throughout the story and I really liked seeing his progress a terrible character love.! Yeah that ’ s been molded by the ending of RDR2 years more experience and is more sad than,! Reading: John Marston vs Arthur Morgan old times sake but if when I want rob! The wrong way of any development through the game yet, so I may be proven wrong later, so!, 2019 in Red Dead redemption ii, Red Dead redemption members of Dutch ’ s my on... At first but by the harness of the west and being raised by Dutch Dutch! John — I do like him, I need to shave a zombie beard a manner of classic Marston....